TY - JOUR
T1 - On the normality of writing
T2 - inscription/description of everyday life
AU - Lubrano, Vittorio
PY - 2019
Y1 - 2019
N2 - Die Buribunken by Carl Schmitt is an uncommon philosophical piece rarely read by non-specialists. Still, with regard to both style – expressionist, satirical, ironic, allusive (2) – and content it exhibits subtle connections with our time and surprising peculiarities that could easily turn it into an unexpected classico. This essay aims to shed a new light on Schmitt’s text, focusing on the act of writing as a procedure for cultural and political control (3.1). The description of life is not a folkloric or neutral aspect of Buribunken society but an inscription of a social norm that affects our being and covers with noble claims of scientific progress the continuous reduction of every element of vitality (3.2). In contrast with traditional conceptions of writing, as both means and end (to reflect on the self and to influence civil progress), a new paradigm is displayed. Paradoxically the subject of writing becomes completely depersonalised and dispossessed by the same activity that was supposed to lead him to his own subjectivity (3.3). Die Buribunken can be reactivated in this respect as a political and cultural fabula for the contemporary reader. Not only as a disillusioned manifesto on the crisis of modernity, nor simply as a sarcastic attempt to depict a hierarchical and excluding society. The interpretation proposed here argues that Schmitt anticipated phenomena such as automatisation, spectacularisation, self-referentiality, mortification of the living, which all share the tendency to orient life coercively into the sphere of information – with the contrary effect of degrading it (4). Whence the urgent need for a radical rethinking of the Humanities, in order to face the long and provocative shadow cast on us by the Buribunkology, so as to renew our understanding of life without reducing it to control and manipulation (5).
AB - Die Buribunken by Carl Schmitt is an uncommon philosophical piece rarely read by non-specialists. Still, with regard to both style – expressionist, satirical, ironic, allusive (2) – and content it exhibits subtle connections with our time and surprising peculiarities that could easily turn it into an unexpected classico. This essay aims to shed a new light on Schmitt’s text, focusing on the act of writing as a procedure for cultural and political control (3.1). The description of life is not a folkloric or neutral aspect of Buribunken society but an inscription of a social norm that affects our being and covers with noble claims of scientific progress the continuous reduction of every element of vitality (3.2). In contrast with traditional conceptions of writing, as both means and end (to reflect on the self and to influence civil progress), a new paradigm is displayed. Paradoxically the subject of writing becomes completely depersonalised and dispossessed by the same activity that was supposed to lead him to his own subjectivity (3.3). Die Buribunken can be reactivated in this respect as a political and cultural fabula for the contemporary reader. Not only as a disillusioned manifesto on the crisis of modernity, nor simply as a sarcastic attempt to depict a hierarchical and excluding society. The interpretation proposed here argues that Schmitt anticipated phenomena such as automatisation, spectacularisation, self-referentiality, mortification of the living, which all share the tendency to orient life coercively into the sphere of information – with the contrary effect of degrading it (4). Whence the urgent need for a radical rethinking of the Humanities, in order to face the long and provocative shadow cast on us by the Buribunkology, so as to renew our understanding of life without reducing it to control and manipulation (5).
KW - Carl Schmitt
KW - Writing
KW - Crisis of modernity
KW - Koselleck
KW - Buribunken
KW - Zoe/bios
KW - Posthumanities
UR - https://www.scopus.com/record/display.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85074388378&doi=10.1080%2f10383441.2019.1646200&origin=inward&txGid=cd35002104b148a4d4b8dba057da13e9
UR - https://apps.webofknowledge.com/InboundService.do?product=WOS&Func=Frame&DestFail=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.webofknowledge.com&SrcApp=RRC&locale=pt_BR&SrcAuth=RRC&SID=E1sh2vef8hblIqGTRwu&customersID=RRC&mode=FullRecord&IsProductCode=Yes&Init=Yes&action=retrieve&UT=WOS%3A000491792700001
U2 - 10.1080/10383441.2019.1646200
DO - 10.1080/10383441.2019.1646200
M3 - Article
VL - 28
SP - 173
EP - 188
JO - Griffith Law Review
JF - Griffith Law Review
SN - 1038-3441
IS - 2
ER -