TY - JOUR
T1 - NOA method – three dimensions in the governance of kidney transplantation
T2 - Need-Opportunity-Accessibility, how to engage them?
AU - Severino, Paulo Filipe
AU - Bolotinha, Catarina
AU - Papoila, Ana Luísa
AU - Brás-Geraldes, Carlos
AU - Dos Santos, Alexandrina
AU - Palmeiro, Vanda Rute Patrício
AU - Fernandes, Ana Paula
AU - Franca, Ana
N1 - Funding Information:
We thank Professor Helder Trindade to promote the study and investigation, Dr. Jo?o Paulo Almeida Sousa for supporting the research, and ONT ? Organizaci?n Nacional de Trasplantes for data supplementation. The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2021
PY - 2021/1
Y1 - 2021/1
N2 - Background: Despite all efforts, the demand for organs increases. New and better strategies are still needed, critical in a crisis like pandemics. Methodology: A mathematical approach that integrates need, Opportunity, and Accessibility to kidney transplantation, was created. NOA method, corresponds to the lateral surface area of a trigonal pyramid with the need, Opportunity, and Accessibility as axis, resulting in an intuitional chart output (NOA chart) and a percentage score (NOA score). Higher NOA scores are associated with larger NOA chart areas. Method Application: We found some natural variability among the European Member States regarding Need, Opportunity, and Accessibility to kidney transplantation, concomitant with NOA scores. In 2019, in the European Union, 129 patients pmp on the waiting list for a kidney transplant were registered, 47 kidneys pmp were procured, and 36 kidneys pmp were transplanted, corresponding to 25% of kidney transplantation's response capacity. Conclusion: Transplantation is frequently the better treatment for end-stage kidney failure. NOA method may be, in the future, an indicator for evaluating the overall transplantation performance regarding the need for it and a tool for policy definition. With NOA method we seek to contribute for: • A transplantation overall performance normalizing score; • Transplantation response capacity evaluation.
AB - Background: Despite all efforts, the demand for organs increases. New and better strategies are still needed, critical in a crisis like pandemics. Methodology: A mathematical approach that integrates need, Opportunity, and Accessibility to kidney transplantation, was created. NOA method, corresponds to the lateral surface area of a trigonal pyramid with the need, Opportunity, and Accessibility as axis, resulting in an intuitional chart output (NOA chart) and a percentage score (NOA score). Higher NOA scores are associated with larger NOA chart areas. Method Application: We found some natural variability among the European Member States regarding Need, Opportunity, and Accessibility to kidney transplantation, concomitant with NOA scores. In 2019, in the European Union, 129 patients pmp on the waiting list for a kidney transplant were registered, 47 kidneys pmp were procured, and 36 kidneys pmp were transplanted, corresponding to 25% of kidney transplantation's response capacity. Conclusion: Transplantation is frequently the better treatment for end-stage kidney failure. NOA method may be, in the future, an indicator for evaluating the overall transplantation performance regarding the need for it and a tool for policy definition. With NOA method we seek to contribute for: • A transplantation overall performance normalizing score; • Transplantation response capacity evaluation.
KW - Need for transplantation response
KW - NOA method
KW - Transplantation accessibility
KW - Transplantation governance
KW - Transplantation need
KW - Transplantation opportunity
KW - Transplantation overall performance
KW - Transplantation policy decision
KW - Transplantation program evaluation
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85116857920&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.mex.2021.101542
DO - 10.1016/j.mex.2021.101542
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85116857920
VL - 8
JO - MethodsX
JF - MethodsX
M1 - 101542
ER -