Lutas por reconhecimento e vontade de poder: uma afinidade entre Hegel e Nietzsche?

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The article is an attempt to explore a controversial hypothesis, which can be stated like this: there is a deep affinity – hitherto largely unnoticed – between Hegel’s conception of struggles for “recognition” (Anerkennung) and Nietzsche’s conception of the dynamics of “will to power” (Wille zur Macht.) This hypothesis concerns the ways in which struggle and domination are implicitly involved in the Hegelian notion of recognition, that is: it concerns the intersubjective dynamics of failed-recognition. Struggle and domination (as well as violence) are crucial concepts in Hegel’s whole conception of recognition – but they are for him operative concepts, whereas in Nietzsche they become thematic, because the concept of “power” becomes thematic. What the article tries to show is that the Nietzschean hypothesis of “will to power” is relevant for the contemporary debate on “recognition and power” because it enables an adequate description of the intersubjective dynamics in which reciprocal recognition is not achieved and relationships of struggle and domination persist, i.e., what persists is “will to power” qua will to domination. However, this is only so because the Nietzschean hypothesis of “will to power” entails a “doctrine of the affects”, and hence a conception of “power” (Macht) in terms of “action at a distance”, i.e., in terms of intersubjective influence mediated by perceptions, interpretations, and perspectives. This conception of “power” entails a “recognitive” conception of human desire and human will, and, therefore, it would be wrong to claim that Nietzsche’s “will to power” involves the dissolution of power-relations in trans-subjective processes of domination. Hence the affinity between Hegel and Nietzsche which the article tries to evince.
Original languagePortuguese
Pages (from-to)88-144
Number of pages56
JournalCadernos Nietzsche (São Paulo)
Volume37
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2016

Keywords

  • Nietzsche
  • Hegel
  • Recognition
  • Power

Cite this