Going beyond the “common suspects”: to be presumed innocent in the era of algorithms, big data and artificial intelligence

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

3 Citations (Scopus)
14 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This article explores the trend of increasing automation in law enforcement and criminal justice settings through three use cases: predictive policing, machine evidence and recidivism algorithms. The focus lies on artificial-intelligence-driven tools and technologies employed, whether at pre-investigation stages or within criminal proceedings, in order to decode human behaviour and facilitate decision-making as to whom to investigate, arrest, prosecute, and eventually punish. In this context, this article first underlines the existence of a persistent dilemma between the goal of increasing the operational efficiency of police and judicial authorities and that of safeguarding fundamental rights of the affected individuals. Subsequently, it shifts the focus onto key principles of criminal procedure and the presumption of innocence in particular. Using Article 6 ECHR and the Directive (EU) 2016/343 as a starting point, it discusses challenges relating to the protective scope of presumption of innocence, the burden of proof rule and the in dubio pro reo principle as core elements of it. Given the transformations law enforcement and criminal proceedings go through in the era of algorithms, big data and artificial intelligence, this article advocates the adoption of specific procedural safeguards that will uphold rule of law requirements, and particularly transparency, fairness and explainability. In doing so, it also takes into account EU legislative initiatives, including the reform of the EU data protection acquis, the E-evidence Proposal, and the Proposal for an EU AI Act. Additionally, it argues in favour of revisiting the protective scope of key fundamental rights, considering, inter alia, the new dimensions suspicion has acquired.
Original languageEnglish
JournalArtificial Intelligence and Law
Volume31
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 22 Feb 2023

Keywords

  • big data
  • artificial intelligence
  • criminal justice
  • law enforcement
  • EU AI Act
  • predictive policing
  • machine evidence
  • recidivism algorithms
  • fundamental rights
  • presumption of innocence

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Going beyond the “common suspects”: to be presumed innocent in the era of algorithms, big data and artificial intelligence'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this