Argumentation in Prime Minister’s Question Time

Accusation of inconsistency in response to criticism

Research output: Book/ReportBook

Abstract

When political actors respond to criticism by pointing at an inconsistency in the critic’s position, a tricky political practice emerges. Turning the criticism back to the critic can be a constructive move that restores coherence, but it may also be a disruptive move that silences the critical voice and obstructs accountability. What distinguishes constructive cases from disruptive ones? This is the question this book sets out to answer.

The question is addressed by adopting an argumentative perspective. Argumentation in Prime Minister’s Question Time focuses on the turnabout employed by the British Prime Minister in response to the Leader of the Opposition. The turnabout is characterised as a particular way of strategic manoeuvring. The manoeuvring is analysed and evaluated by combining pragmatic, dialectical and rhetorical insights with considerations from the realm of politics. The outcome is an account of the turnabout’s strategic functions and an assessment guide for evaluating its reasonableness.

The book will be of interest to advanced students and researchers of argumentation, discourse analysis, communication and rhetoric.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationAmsterdam
PublisherJohn Benjamins
Number of pages162
VolumeAiC 15
ISBN (Electronic)9789027263278
ISBN (Print)9789027201744
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 30 Nov 2018

Publication series

NameArgumentation in Context
PublisherJohn Benjamins
Volume15

Fingerprint

argumentation
minister
critic
criticism
reasonableness
political actor
discourse analysis
rhetoric
pragmatics
opposition
leader
responsibility
politics
communication
student
time
coherence

Cite this

@book{3e3a4dfa968e4e24a882c48a6fe7830c,
title = "Argumentation in Prime Minister’s Question Time: Accusation of inconsistency in response to criticism",
abstract = "When political actors respond to criticism by pointing at an inconsistency in the critic’s position, a tricky political practice emerges. Turning the criticism back to the critic can be a constructive move that restores coherence, but it may also be a disruptive move that silences the critical voice and obstructs accountability. What distinguishes constructive cases from disruptive ones? This is the question this book sets out to answer. The question is addressed by adopting an argumentative perspective. Argumentation in Prime Minister’s Question Time focuses on the turnabout employed by the British Prime Minister in response to the Leader of the Opposition. The turnabout is characterised as a particular way of strategic manoeuvring. The manoeuvring is analysed and evaluated by combining pragmatic, dialectical and rhetorical insights with considerations from the realm of politics. The outcome is an account of the turnabout’s strategic functions and an assessment guide for evaluating its reasonableness. The book will be of interest to advanced students and researchers of argumentation, discourse analysis, communication and rhetoric.",
author = "Dima Mohammed",
note = "info:eu-repo/grantAgreement/FCT/5876/147240/PT# UID/FIL/00183/2013",
year = "2018",
month = "11",
day = "30",
doi = "10.1075/aic.15",
language = "English",
isbn = "9789027201744",
volume = "AiC 15",
series = "Argumentation in Context",
publisher = "John Benjamins",

}

Argumentation in Prime Minister’s Question Time : Accusation of inconsistency in response to criticism. / Mohammed, Dima.

Amsterdam : John Benjamins, 2018. 162 p. (Argumentation in Context; Vol. 15).

Research output: Book/ReportBook

TY - BOOK

T1 - Argumentation in Prime Minister’s Question Time

T2 - Accusation of inconsistency in response to criticism

AU - Mohammed, Dima

N1 - info:eu-repo/grantAgreement/FCT/5876/147240/PT# UID/FIL/00183/2013

PY - 2018/11/30

Y1 - 2018/11/30

N2 - When political actors respond to criticism by pointing at an inconsistency in the critic’s position, a tricky political practice emerges. Turning the criticism back to the critic can be a constructive move that restores coherence, but it may also be a disruptive move that silences the critical voice and obstructs accountability. What distinguishes constructive cases from disruptive ones? This is the question this book sets out to answer. The question is addressed by adopting an argumentative perspective. Argumentation in Prime Minister’s Question Time focuses on the turnabout employed by the British Prime Minister in response to the Leader of the Opposition. The turnabout is characterised as a particular way of strategic manoeuvring. The manoeuvring is analysed and evaluated by combining pragmatic, dialectical and rhetorical insights with considerations from the realm of politics. The outcome is an account of the turnabout’s strategic functions and an assessment guide for evaluating its reasonableness. The book will be of interest to advanced students and researchers of argumentation, discourse analysis, communication and rhetoric.

AB - When political actors respond to criticism by pointing at an inconsistency in the critic’s position, a tricky political practice emerges. Turning the criticism back to the critic can be a constructive move that restores coherence, but it may also be a disruptive move that silences the critical voice and obstructs accountability. What distinguishes constructive cases from disruptive ones? This is the question this book sets out to answer. The question is addressed by adopting an argumentative perspective. Argumentation in Prime Minister’s Question Time focuses on the turnabout employed by the British Prime Minister in response to the Leader of the Opposition. The turnabout is characterised as a particular way of strategic manoeuvring. The manoeuvring is analysed and evaluated by combining pragmatic, dialectical and rhetorical insights with considerations from the realm of politics. The outcome is an account of the turnabout’s strategic functions and an assessment guide for evaluating its reasonableness. The book will be of interest to advanced students and researchers of argumentation, discourse analysis, communication and rhetoric.

U2 - 10.1075/aic.15

DO - 10.1075/aic.15

M3 - Book

SN - 9789027201744

VL - AiC 15

T3 - Argumentation in Context

BT - Argumentation in Prime Minister’s Question Time

PB - John Benjamins

CY - Amsterdam

ER -